> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://groundthatholds.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Exodus Is Real
- URL: https://groundthatholds.com/the-exodus-is-real/
- Published: 2026-11-17T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T15:00:01.000Z
- Author: Brandon Carneiro

*The moving trucks are real, and so is the fight over what they take with them.*

> "When the king of Egypt was told that the people had fled, Pharaoh and his officials changed their minds about them and said, 'What have we done? We have let the Israelites go and have lost their services!'"   
> (Exodus 14:5 NIV)

Pharaoh's officials were not grieving the people. They were grieving the work.

That is the whole economy of Egypt in one sentence. It ran on people who could not leave. The bricks, the storehouses, the cities all assumed the labor would be there in the morning. The day the people walked out, Egypt learned what they had been worth, and it learned it by losing them.

No American state can run that way today. No state can stop you at its border. No state can make you ask permission to go. Every one of them has to give you a reason to stay.

In the year ending July 2025, California lost about two hundred twenty-nine thousand more people to other states than it gained from them. No state lost more. California was one of only five states whose population fell.

I will be honest about what that number proves. It proves people are leaving. It does not prove why. People move for weather, for family, for a cheaper house, for a better job. The very rich, the ones everyone argues about, mostly never move at all.

So I will not guess at their motives. I will tell you what the governor of California believes about them.

This month California voted on a one-time tax on billionaires, put on the ballot by a union and endorsed by the state Democratic Party. It set residency on January 1, a date already behind every person who read the ballot. Leave after that, and you would still have owed it. The measure was written so that leaving would not help.

Gavin Newsom fought it. He warned that the people it targeted could leave and take future tax revenue with them.

Hear what that means. The governor of the largest blue state in America told his own party that the people funding his government could walk if pushed. That is not my argument. It is his. He was not describing a theory. He was describing his own tax base.

And the confessions keep coming from inside. San Francisco recalled its own district attorney. Oregon decriminalized hard drugs by popular vote and, less than four years later, under a Democratic governor, made possession a crime again. Nobody from outside forced any of it.

Here is the mechanism. A government can tax the people who stay. It cannot generally tax what the people who go earn somewhere else: the next paycheck, the next company, the next hire, the next twenty years of income, earned entirely outside the state. Those leave in the truck. So when the people with the most to take can leave, a government has two choices. It can become a place worth staying in. Or it can start designing the door.

A tax that leaving cannot escape is a door designed.

Nobody in California is a slave, and nobody in Sacramento is Pharaoh. But the temptation is the same one, and it is very old. When people start leaving, make leaving useless.

California's voters refused it. Then they went further. On the same ballot they passed Proposition 42, writing into the state constitution a ban on new state taxes on owning financial assets and limits on most retroactive taxes, the exact mechanisms the billionaire tax was built on. Billionaires paid for that campaign. Voters still had to say yes, and they did. They did not just reject the door. They made the next one harder to build.

The temptation will be back, because the arithmetic that produced it has not changed. Next time it will have to get past the constitution first.

Now the part that should keep the rest of us up at night.

Israel did not leave Egypt for a better deal. When God sent Moses to Pharaoh, the reason He gave was worship. The exodus was not a relocation. It was a summons.

They forgot within months. Camped at the foot of a mountain, tired of waiting for Moses, they took off their gold earrings. Exodus says the Egyptians had handed over their silver and gold as the people left. Aaron took it.

> "He took what they handed him and made it into an idol cast in the shape of a calf, fashioning it with a tool. Then they said, 'These are your gods, Israel, who brought you up out of Egypt.'"   
> (Exodus 32:4 NIV)

They got out of Egypt. Egypt did not get out of them. They took its gold, made its kind of god, and gave it the credit for setting them free.

That is the danger for everyone who leaves, and I am one of them. I left Oregon this summer. I wrote about why in "I Made a Choice." In 2024, California sent more newcomers to Tennessee than any other state did.

I do not know why any particular one of them came. I know the temptations every one of us carries in, me included. There is the old calf: a government that gives everything and asks nothing. And there is the new one, waiting for anyone who moved to get away from the first: a state that asks nothing and expects nothing back. A man who moves for lower taxes and nothing else has not left Egypt. He has found a cheaper one.

Both are calves. One is just cheaper to cast.

The freedom to leave matters. This whole essay depends on it. But in Exodus it was the beginning, never the destination. Israel was set free in order to worship. Freedom from Egypt only meant something because of what it was for: God first, then a family raised in the open, work that serves someone, a church you actually show up to. Leave for that, and the move means something. Leave for anything less, and the gold just goes into the fire somewhere new.

Nashville is not Canaan. I live here. No state becomes the Promised Land because it skips the income tax and has a church on every corner. A moving truck can get you out of a city. It cannot get the city out of you.

Pharaoh's officials asked the right question for the wrong reason. They wanted the labor back.

The cities losing people are asking it now.

The people who left had better ask it too.

Not what we left. What we brought.

---

**Sources**

California's domestic migration loss, U.S. Census Bureau, January 2026, [https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2026/01/pop-estimates-state-change.html](https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2026/01/pop-estimates-state-change.html?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
California voters reject Prop 40, CalMatters via GV Wire, November 9, 2026, [https://gvwire.com/2026/11/09/california-voters-reject-prop-40-billionaire-tax/](https://gvwire.com/2026/11/09/california-voters-reject-prop-40-billionaire-tax/?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
Prop 40's residency date and Newsom's opposition, Fortune, October 21, 2026, [https://fortune.com/2026/10/21/california-billionaire-tax-prop-40-stanford-study-39-billion-loss/](https://fortune.com/2026/10/21/california-billionaire-tax-prop-40-stanford-study-39-billion-loss/?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
California Democratic Party endorses Prop 40, Common Dreams, 2026, [https://www.commondreams.org/news/california-democrats-billionaire-tax](https://www.commondreams.org/news/california-democrats-billionaire-tax?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
Voters pass Proposition 42, Morgan Lewis, November 10, 2026, [https://www.morganlewis.com/pubs/2026/11/california-voters-reject-billionaire-tax-initiative](https://www.morganlewis.com/pubs/2026/11/california-voters-reject-billionaire-tax-initiative?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
Proposition 42 explained, Legislative Analyst's Office, 2026, [https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop42-110326.pdf](https://lao.ca.gov/ballot/2026/prop42-110326.pdf?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
Millionaire migration study, American Sociological Association via ScienceDaily, May 26, 2016, [https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/05/160526091954.htm](https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/05/160526091954.htm?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
San Francisco recalls its district attorney, San Francisco Examiner, December 2022, [https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/2022-one-for-the-sf-history-books-what-will-2023-bring/article\_c5fddc54-7f2e-11ed-8d27-738a805ba32a.html](https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/2022-one-for-the-sf-history-books-what-will-2023-bring/article%5Fc5fddc54-7f2e-11ed-8d27-738a805ba32a.html?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
Oregon recriminalizes drug possession, Ballotpedia News, April 2, 2024, [https://news.ballotpedia.org/2024/04/02/drug-decriminalization-to-recriminalization-oregon-governor-signs-legislative-alteration-of-2020s-measure-110/](https://news.ballotpedia.org/2024/04/02/drug-decriminalization-to-recriminalization-oregon-governor-signs-legislative-alteration-of-2020s-measure-110/?ref=groundthatholds.com)  
  
California as top source of newcomers to Tennessee, Associated Press via San Mateo Daily Journal, January 2026, [https://www.smdailyjournal.com/lifestyle/texas-leads-the-nation-in-supplying-new-residents-to-other-states/article\_14bb4587-0387-5b22-bd95-5db8dc385cb9.html](https://www.smdailyjournal.com/lifestyle/texas-leads-the-nation-in-supplying-new-residents-to-other-states/article%5F14bb4587-0387-5b22-bd95-5db8dc385cb9.html?ref=groundthatholds.com)