Empathy Is Dangerous

Share
Empathy Is Dangerous

Feeling someone's pain is not the same as knowing what is true.

Empathy is dangerous.

Not because feeling for people is wrong. Because we have given empathy a job it was never built to do. We let it decide what is true.

First, give empathy its due, because it has earned it. Empathy notices the suffering everyone else would rather step around. It is the reason a stranger stops on the side of the road. It is the reason people sit with the dying, take in the orphan, and walk into the hard conversation instead of away from it. Institutions ignore pain all the time. Comfortable people ignore it even more. Empathy refuses to. A man who feels nothing for anyone is not strong. He is broken.

So I am not against empathy. I am against promoting it.

Empathy is a good alarm. It is a terrible judge.

A feeling can tell you that someone is hurting. It can't tell you why. It can't tell you what is true. It can't tell you which remedy will heal and which will make things worse. Pain is information. It is not a verdict.

The trouble starts when we treat it as one. Allie Beth Stuckey calls this toxic empathy: empathy used to affirm what is false, validate what is wrong, and support what destroys people.

It happens in a sequence.

First, you feel what someone feels. That part is human and good. Then the feeling hardens into certainty. The pain is so real that whatever the person wants must be right. Then disagreement gets expensive. If the feeling settled the question, anyone who reopens it must not care. Ask whether the remedy actually works and nobody answers you. They ask whether you have a heart.

Once emotional agreement becomes the price of acceptance, some people still hold their ground. Many pay the price instead. They go quiet. They say whatever protects their reputation. That is how empathy, promoted to judge, turns a room full of decent people into a room full of nice ones.

The difference matters. Nice is what you say to stay liked. It protects the speaker. Kind is what you say because you want the other person to be well, even if it costs you their approval. On an easy day you can't tell them apart. On a hard day they split.

Empathy as judge has a second weakness. It concentrates. It locks onto the most compelling face in the room, the one with the story, and the people outside the frame fade. Not because anyone decided they don't matter. Because they never made it into the picture.

In 1999 a prisoner in Arkansas asked his governor, a former Baptist pastor, for clemency. He was serving one hundred and eight years for crimes he committed as a teenager. That sentence is hard to defend, and wanting mercy for him was not foolish. A judge urged clemency. In May 2000 the governor commuted the sentence to forty-seven years, which made him eligible for parole. That July the parole board granted it, over the objections of prosecutors. He walked out in August.

On his application he had checked a box that read: "My institutional adjustment has been exemplary."

The prison's score sheet read: "Disciplinaries: 29 Times. Achievements: None."

He was back in prison within a year. He was paroled again in 2004 and moved to Washington. In 2009 he walked into a coffee shop outside Tacoma and killed four police officers.

I can't tell you what each person weighed, and I won't pretend to. The case does not prove empathy caused anything. What the record shows is a claim of exemplary conduct, a file that said otherwise, and a release anyway. Both were on paper. Mercy can be right and still owe the file a hearing.

Nobody could have named those officers in 2000. Nobody can name future victims. That was never the standard. The standard is to weigh the risks you can see, on behalf of the people you can't.

You don't need a governor's pen to face a smaller version of that test. Every hard conversation is one. Niceness tends to fail it, and it isn't free. Every comfortable thing you say in place of a true thing spends a little of your integrity, until your words stop meaning anything. Truth costs more up front. It costs you the room. It can cost you a friendship. It will often cost you your reputation for being loving, even when telling the truth is the most loving thing anyone does for that person all year.

Call it harsh. Call me uncompassionate. Compassion is why I speak. Truth decides what I say.

None of this is a license to humiliate. Plenty of people hide cruelty behind "I'm just being honest." They enjoy the wound more than they care about the person. That is the same selfishness as niceness, pointed the other way.

If I get called harsh for telling the truth, that is the cost. If I earn the word, that is on me.

Mark records a wealthy man who ran up to Jesus, fell on his knees, and asked what he had to do to inherit eternal life.

"Jesus looked at him and loved him. 'One thing you lack,' he said. 'Go, sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me'"
(Mark 10:21, NIV)

Notice the order. Jesus loved him first. Then He told him the one thing he did not want to hear.

The man went away sad. Jesus let him go. He did not chase him with a softer offer or lower the price to keep him in the room. The man's sorrow did not make the love false, and it did not make the instruction wrong.

Love did not make the truth negotiable. Not even to keep him.

Compassion that bends the truth to spare a feeling can leave a person exactly where it found him. Sometimes it hands the bill to people who were never in the room.


Sources

Toxic Empathy: How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion, Allie Beth Stuckey, Sentinel, October 2024,
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/210454061

Persuasive appeal helped Clemmons win clemency, The Seattle Times, November 30, 2009,
https://special.seattletimes.com/o/html/localnews/2010392867_shootingclemency01m.html

Huckabee granted clemency to killer despite record, Fox News, December 2009,
https://www.foxnews.com/us/huckabee-granted-clemency-to-killer-despite-record

Maurice Clemmons fact sheet, Prison Legal News, 2009,
https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/publications/maurice-clemmons-fact-sheet-2009/